Author interview: Scott M. Bushnell, Hard News, Heartfelt Opinions

Through the story of the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette, Scott M. Bushnell presents the political history of Fort Wayne, Allen County, and Indiana's northeastern region. With an informal tone and the snappy style of a seasoned journalist, Bushnell explores just how integrally newspapers were linked to, and even shaped, political events.

Recently the IU Press blog interviewed Bushnell about his latest book:

IU Press blog: How did a Poughkeepsie, NY native become involved in writing a history of a Fort Wayne, Indiana newspaper?

Scott Bushnell: When I was growing up, New York required eighth graders to take a full year of state history. I can still remember a giant map I made of the state, freckled with labels of products made in the various cities – Yonkers, Albany, Rochester, Syracuse, Buffalo, Binghamton, Ithaca and Poughkeepsie (home of IBM, Smith Bros. cough drops, Dell Comics and Vassar College). It instilled an appreciation for the unique aspects of New York’s communities and their histories. And, since I lived in a city on the noble Hudson River, I was especially interested in those along its rivers. My years as a reporter taught me that local government was the essence of American democracy, but that this “essence” was determined by the locales’ history. This helped me support one of my reporters when he struggled to uncover the PCB pollution in the Housatonic River in Connecticut. When I came to Fort Wayne – where two rivers join to form a third – there was a talented, credentialed historian here whose work convinced me that this was an area with a story to tell: that it had a proud past of which the present generation was generally unaware.

IUPB: In the introduction of your book, you write that as a small American city, Fort Wayne deserves more attention. Why do you feel this way?

SB: Cities like Fort Wayne are often overlooked in favor of state capitals or metropolitan areas. If one wants to have greater insight, or a clearer understanding, of such issues as the so-called Midwest work ethic or its entrepreneurial spirit, it can be found in the history of the small Midwestern cities. I believe that if you want to understand individual capitalism and the path to economic success, you ought to examine the lives of Sylvanus Bowser or Theodore Thieme – both successful Fort Wayne industrialists at the turn of the 20th century. It was, and is, the individual inventiveness and the access to local capital that has been the backbone of the nation’s strength. I think this has been clearly shown on a regional basis by Midwest historian Andrew R.L. Cayton and ought to be studied on a small-city basis further.

IUPB: The Journal Gazette is known as the liberal paper in Fort Wayne, while its competitor The News Sentinel is considered to be conservative. How do newspapers’ affinities toward liberal or conservative positions affect the reporting of the news?

SB: The notion of a “liberal newsroom” is one of the great lies of our time, often propagated, it seems to me, by folks whose partisanship makes them less willing to examine two sides of a complex issue. The editorial position of a modern day newspaper affects it editorials, not its reporting. There is more emphasis now than ever before on objectivity and accuracy in journalism schools and in newsrooms.

IUPB: A dynamic personality who stands out in the history of the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette is publisher Andrew Joseph Moynihan. What is your favorite story about him? On a more serious note, what do you feel was his most important contribution to the success of the paper?

SB: The Moynihan stories are legion and the book has most of my favorites. His meteoric personality and unmistakable ability to find and train talented young journalists were Moynihan’s great strengths. This proved true when he identified Lewis Ellingham as his successor at the Journal-Gazette. Ellingham made it a modern paper of its time.

IUPB: Many newspapers are publicly owned, yet a private company operates the Journal Gazette. What are the advantages or disadvantages of private vs. public ownership, and what is the impact upon newspapers and their readers?

SB: The demise of Knight Ridder Corporation is indicative of the disadvantages of a publicly owned newspaper or newspaper chain. The Knight Ridder shareholders decided they were not making enough profit and put all of the chain’s newspapers for sale. They received their profits when the newspapers were divvied up among other newspaper corporations. One drawback is that these other corporations, while well-intended, lack financial capability to pursue important news around the world as Knight Ridder did.

And this is just one example of a loss to the American reader.

IUPB: How do you think the increase in people reading the news online will impact the future of the Journal Gazette and the newspaper industry in general?

SB: It may not seem so now, but it is a good thing that online news has occurred. It is increasing young readers’ appetite for news and for understanding our complex world. Its brevity will drive many young readers to seek more information – broadcast, blogs, books, magazines and, yes, even newspapers. Newspapers learned how to package news and advertising in the 19th century and find ways to get it into the hands of the readers. For example, the Journal-Gazette and most other small city newspapers used to print mid-week weekly editions that were mailed to readers beyond the delivery distance of a horse-drawn vehicle. These editions carried summaries and actual articles that had been printed in the daily issues, enabling farmers and their families to be current on national, state and local issues. These weekly editions disappeared in the Fort Wayne area around the time of World War I as motorized vehicles became more common for daily newspaper delivery. Similarly, newspaper design has changed over the years to a more visual layout, reflecting the readers’ preferences. The challenge of news online will – and is – bringing about changes to the Journal Gazette and the rest of the newspaper industry.

IUPB: As a Fort Wayne native, I was intrigued by the history of the Journal Gazette. What can others who aren’t from Fort Wayne or the region learn from reading this history of a small American city newspaper?
 
SB: Hard News, Heartfelt Opinions is, at its roots, a paean to newspapering. Yes, the book is about a certain group of people at a certain period of time. Yes, it is a look at Midwestern American society and how it addressed the issues of its day. And, yes, it is also a tribute to the men and women of a great profession, dedicated to preserving freedom of the press in Fort Wayne and the rest of northeastern Indiana every day.

But it is a bit more than that, too: It is meant to look at the difference between news and history. The Journal Gazette reported the news of the day and this book tries to see now if the paper’s perspective on the news proved historically accurate. For example, The Daily Gazette subscribed to a telegraphic service during the Civil War and it reported on the Union victory at Gettysburg while its opposition (without a wire service) claimed the Confederate Army had not been defeated. Readers of both newspapers responded strongly to what they read and therefore believed.

This may seem very obvious, but it is an important facet for today’s world and its addiction to constant “news.” What was seen as an undisputable historic news event in 1907 is now viewed as inconsequential, regardless of the uproar it caused 100 years ago. This ought to be considered when a news bulletin today captures our passions. It may be very mundane tomorrow.

Comments

[Lewis Ellingham]

I am the grandson of Lewis G. Ellingham, featured in "Hard News, Heartfelt Opinion". On page 91, Opening Chapter 5, there is the genealogical datum that Lewis (Glendale) Ellingham was the son of parents born in Scotland. In fact they were born in parishes now part of Coventry, UK, which was then in the shire of Warwick and now is in a newly created English county. They emigrated from Coventry circa 1830 to Canada and then Ohio, then by the mid-1830s to Wells Co., IN, and were farmers there. I have published on this, as "Two Coventry Shoemakers Become Indiana Farmers". Since LGE's mother's maiden name was Scotten, perhaps that is the source of this small error. I have posted the full Ellingham genealogy on websites and it is on paper at the Fort Wayne / Allen County, Indiana, Public Library's Genealogy Department. Anyone interested in knowing more about all this may contact me personally in San Francisco, CA. My contact can be found at switchboard.com on the web. -Lewis Ellingham (10=X-2007)